Home Advertise Contact Blog Advertiser Login RSS
Newsletter Signup

Buy A Business Opportunity of Franchise
Home-Based Businesses
Choosing a Business Opportunity Growth and Profit Marketing and Sales
Plans and Goals Running Your Own Business Start-Up
Working From Home Entrepreneur Exchange Feature Articles
Opportunity Community Opportunity Focus In The News

Happy first day of December! It’s December and the end of the year is in full-swing. Don’t go into the holiday travel season without the December Book-of-the-Month: Business Adventures by John Brooks.

December means that its holiday time. No matter what holiday you celebrate it’ll...

Female celebrities are breaking the stereotypes of Hollywood and diving into the world of business. Check out how these women are using their fame, fortune, and power to start their own companies. From media production to makeup, these Top Female Celebrity Business Owners are doing it all!

As...

With only a few weeks lefts in 2017, it’s time to get organized now! The holidays are around the corner and you don’t want to be scrambling at the end of the year. Use these Small Business Organization and Tax Tips to End 2017 to help you keep the end of the year stress to a minimum.

Happy...

Sponsors

STARSCAPES®
Imagine making up to $500 to $1,800 a day! Call or click now see how you can get your business for FREE! (602) 679-0257
Promotional Products Home Business
Run Your Own Business. Be Your Own Boss. Earn Great Profit Potential. Start At A Low Cost. Try It For Free! Learn More.
Residual Income Business Opportunities
Residual Income is the way that you work once and get paid multiple times—sounds great!... Read On
Top 7 Reasons to Consider a CMS
The internet loves obscure abbreviations. You can skip over most of them, but not CMS. What is CMS? read on...
The Ideal Length of Everything Online, Including Social Media Posts
When one of your busiest marketing channels limits you to 140 characters, you know that the internet sets its own rules.
Low Cost Business Opportunities to Own
Are your right for a Low Cost Business Opportunities to Own? The desire to own your own business... Read On
Why Advertise Your Business Opportunity?
Over the years we have been fortunate enough to receive quite a few testimonials. In fact, ... read on
National Property Inspections
Flexible work schedule, no experience needed, and complete training and support available!
How Many Leads Does It Take To Close A Sale?
This Featured Article is live on our blog and I know could be very insightful for connectivity and ROI.
Top 50 Home-Based Business Ideas
Home-Based Business ownership can be the most rewarding endeavor you will ever undertake. The new year... Read On
I Want To Buy a Business Opportunity or Franchise
Who are the types of people who buy a business opportunity or small franchise? According to people in... Read on
Copying & Publishing Business Opportunities
Today creativity abounds in the printing and publishing space with more unique business solutions than ever imaginable.
 
Resource Center > Article
Supreme Court Amazon Smackdown Highlights Internet Sales Tax Issue Once Again
6 Dec 13 Posted by: Kathleen C Lanza
in In The News
Share this Article:

Ironically, the U.S. Supreme Court chose Cyber Monday, which is swiftly becoming the busiest day of the year for many online retailers, to issue its refusal to hear the latest in a string of cases dating back decades regarding whether or not sellers must collect sales taxes when they engage in interstate commerce.
While the cases of old dealt with the transport of goods across state lines and mail-order sales more specifically, the basic question, even when applied to internet commerce and online sales tax as it exists today remains the same…

Under what circumstances is it necessary for the sellers of goods to collect state sales tax when the goods that they sell are being sold out of the state in which the seller resides, or at the very least has some physical presence?

It’s a good, yet extremely complex, question — one that doesn’t seem headed for unilateral resolution anytime soon, especially given Monday’s so-called non-decision. GavMOney6The New York State Online Sales Tax Debate

The Supreme Court’s announcement that it will steer clear of this most recent case altogether constitutes a de facto decision to uphold a 2008 New York Court State of Appeals ruling requiring online retailers like Amazon to collect sales tax from their customers in the state of New York, no matter what the circumstances.

Amazon, along with its smaller competitor Overstock, was challenging that decision in this latest case by claiming that neither retailer has what reasonably could be referred to as a “physical presence” in the state enough to warrant such compliance. As of now, the basic rule is that states may not collect taxes from companies that do not have some physical presence in their state.

However, given that state budgets are so tight right now, that basic premise is being challenged all over the place and for a host of reasons. Primary among them is the argument by brick-and-mortar stores that online retailers are at a huge competitive advantage given that they all too often do not have to collect sales tax on the goods that they sell.

And even in cases where they should, many of them just plain don’t…and they get away with it too. Why? With fifty states, all with individual tax rates in the mix — not to mention use taxes and what all they entail, it’s all a big mess. One that is too big to regulate with any degree of certainty, at least as it stands right now.

Physical Presence

Also in the mix of challenges is the whole debate over what constitutes any one business’ “physical presence” in a given state. According to the 2008 ruling, Amazon must collect sales taxes on purchases made by New York residents because, while it doesn’t have a home office, distribution center or even a warehouse in the state, it does partner with N.Y.-based specialized retailers to fulfill orders on some items. This, the Court said, constitutes an “in-state sales force” of sorts.

Writing for the majority in that case, Chief Judge Jonathan Lippman conceded that the physical presence litmus test is an approach that may be outdated. “The world has changed dramatically in the last two decades,” he said. “An entity may now have a profound impact upon a foreign jurisdiction solely through its virtual projection via the Internet.”

He went on to state that the question perhaps would be an appropriate one for the U.S. Supreme Court. Obviously, the Court would beg to differ given Monday’s announcement.

An Intractable Problem with No Easy Solutions

For now, there are no easy solutions where the collection of online sales tax across state lines is concerned.

While there was some encouraging movement in the U.S. Senate on this issue in the last year as efforts to create some sort of unified policy across all fifty states seemingly met with a fair amount of support, that has now been overshadowed by more squabbling.

In fact, that development triggered a groundswell of somewhat intractable debate, primarily in the House, where a number of additional bills both for and against various aspects of the many challenges posed by online interstate commerce are in the offing.

At the end of the day, most agree that the need for federal legislation of some kind to resolve the issue once and for all is needed, but simplicity and uniformity of any kind is hardly the order of the day in Congress right now. This we all know too well.

So the debate goes on, and the uncertainty about who is paying what, how, when and to where or whom on any given day where the sale and purchase of goods online is concerned remains an enigma of the highest order.

Read more about these latest developments on this issue now at:

The New York Times

Forbes

Bloomberg News

And for more on BusinessOpportunity.com’s past coverage on this issue:

The Amazon Tax Debate: Where Do You Stand? January 2011

“Amazon Tax” Debate Rages on in America’s Most Populous State, July 2011

Online Shopping Tax Debate Heats Up Once Again, February 2013

Online Business Sales Tax One Giant Step Closer to Passage, April 2013

Sales Tax Fairness Map Nov-2013.001-001

 

Related Blog Posts
8 Dec 17 Posted by: Margaret Mallonée
in In The News

Always wondered what happened to your favorite athletes after they retired? Check out these Athletes Turned Successful Entrepreneurs!

It’s a great time of year for sports – basketball, football, the World Cup group draw, and more. It seems there is something for every sports lover this time...
22 Nov 17 Posted by: Margaret Mallonée
in In The News

It’s the Wednesday before Thanksgiving! Everyone is gearing up for not only the biggest feast of the year, but also some of the best deals of the year. Don’t miss out on these Cyber Monday and Black Friday Deals 2017!

Black Friday, Small Business Saturday, and Cyber Monday are fantastic times...
8 Nov 17 Posted by: Margaret Mallonée
in In The News

As we approach the holiday season, companies are pushing out their hottest, new products to top our wish lists. In the battle of iPhone X vs Samsung Galaxy Note 8 - Best for Business Owners, which will reign supreme?

iPhone X vs Samsung Galaxy Note 8 – Best Option for Business Owners? November...
14 Sep 17 Posted by: Kevin James Culp
in In The News
Everyone will be hearing a lot from the newest addition to our staff: Digital Marketing Manager Hired Margaret Mallonée! This hire was a strategic move to enhance our staff for the new digital media platform we will be introducing in the weeks and months to come. Chicago,...
15 Sep 16 Posted by: Kevin James Culp
in In The News

Expanding Opportunity Services - It has always been our mission to provide the best customer service possible and have recently added no cost training and coaching sessions for all active advertisers. Now, we are going a step further to address the one major problem faced by opportunity owners–lack...

 
   

I had the pleasure of chatting with Shawn Pigg, CEO of Hotels Etc. for BusinessOpportunity.com's Podcast series that will be released very soon on our new Digital Platform.  Here is the transcript from that call for our regular RSS feed subscribers who get all of our posts first.

If you would...
Read More


Premium Sponsor